Most images on the web are superfluous. If I might be a jerk for a bit, 99% of them aren’t event that helpful at all (although there are rare exceptions). That’s because images don’t often complement the text they’re supposed to support and instead hurt users, taking forever to load and blowing up data caps like some sort of performance tax.
Thankfully, this is mostly a design problem today because making images performant and more user-friendly is so much easier than it once was. We have better image formats like WebP (and soon, perhaps, JPEG XL). We have the magic of responsive images of course. And there are tons of great tools out there, like ImageOptim, as well as resources such as Addy Osmani’s new book.
Although perhaps my favorite way to improve image performance is with lazy loading:
<img href="image.webp" alt="Image description" loading="lazy">This image will only load when a user scrolls down the page so it’s visible to the user — which removes it from the initial page load and that’s just great! Making that initial load of a webpage lightning fast is a big deal.
But maybe there are images that should never load at all. Perhaps there are situations where it’d be better if a person could opt-into seeing it. Here’s one example: take the text-only version of NPR and click around for a bit. Isn’t it… just so great?! It’s readable! There’s no junk all over the place, it respects me as a user and — sweet heavens — is it fast.
So! What if we could show images on a website but only once they are clicked or tapped? Wouldn’t it be neat if we could show a placeholder and swap it out for the real image on click? Something like this:
Well, I had two thoughts here as to how to build this chap (the golden rule is that there’s never one way to build anything on the web).
Method #1: Using <img> without a src attribute
We can remove the src attribute of an <img> tag to hide an image. We could then put the image file in an attribute, like data-src or something, just like this:
<img data-src="image.jpg" src="" alt="Photograph of hot air balloons by Musab Al Rawahi. 144kb">By default, most browsers will show a broken image icon that you’re probably familiar with:
Okay, so it’s sort of accessible. I guess? You can see the alt tag rendered on screen automatically, but with a light dash of JavaScript, we can then swap out the src with that attribute:
document.querySelectorAll("img").forEach((item) => { item.addEventListener("click", (event) => { const image = event.target.getAttribute("data-src"); event.target.setAttribute("src", image); });
});Now we can add some styles and ugh, oh no:
Ugh. In some browsers there’ll be a tiny broken image icon in the bottom when the image hasn’t loaded. The problem here is that browsers don’t give you a way to remove the broken image icon with CSS (and we probably shouldn’t be allowed to anyway). It’s a bit annoying to style the alt text, too. But if we remove the alt attribute altogether, then the broken image icon is gone, although this makes the <img> unusable without JavaScript. So removing that alt text is a no-go.
As I said: Ugh. I don’t think there’s a way to make this method work (although please prove me wrong!).
Method #2: Using links to create an image
The other option we have is to start with the humble hyperlink, like this:
<a href="image.jpg">Photograph of hot air balloons by Musab Al Rawahi. 144kb<a>Which, yep, nothing smart happening yet — this will just render a link to an image:
That works accessibility-wise, right? If we don’t have any JavaScript, then all we have is just a link that folks can optionally click. Performance-wise, it can’t get much faster than plain text!
But from here, we can reach for JavaScript to stop the link from loading on click, grab the href attribute within that link, create an image element and, finally, throw that image on the page and remove the old link once we’re done:
document.querySelectorAll(".load-image").forEach((item) => { item.addEventListener("click", (event) => { const href = event.target.getAttribute("href"); const newImage = document.createElement("img"); event.preventDefault(); newImage.setAttribute("src", href); document.body.insertBefore(newImage, event.target); event.target.remove(); });
});We could probably style this placeholder link to make it look a bit nicer than what I have below. But this is just an example. Go ahead and click the link to load the image again:
And there you have it! It isn’t groundbreaking or anything, and I’m sure someone’s done this before at some point or another. But if we wanted to be extremely radical about performance beyond the first paint and initial load, then I think this is an okay-ish solution. If we’re making a text-only website then I think this is definitely the way to go.
Perhaps we could also make a web component out of this, or even detect if someone has prefers-reduced-data and then only load images if someone has enough data or something. What do you think?
